I bought two Hurley toys. I have a yellow lab and she is 3 years old. I also have a chocolate lab and he is 11 months old. I have been buying toys, about 4 a week, and they rip them up almost immediately . I proceed to the next rough and tough toy that I see in the store and it is shredded in a night or two. They have had their toys for 3 weeks now and no puncture wounds on the toys at all. I am very happy with these toys and so are my babies. I am definitely going to be buying these toys for my friends and family for Christmas. You will NOT be disappointed!!!