I love the look and colors and especially the durability of the Hurleys. But none of our 13 dogs think they are interesting, even when we try to initiate games with them using the Hurleys. I've never seen one of the dogs interacting with a Hurley. This in spite of the fact that these dogs really are toy crazy. (Unfortunately they sometimes MAKE toys out of objects that should NOT be.)
I tossed 3 new Hurleys on the porch when received last week. 2 are still where they fell. :(
For design, made in USA, durability, colors (that are easy to spot wherever they are) - I give the Hurley a solid 5 stars. For attractiveness to dogs (I have Aussies, Australian Cattle Dogs, a Rottweiler and one small dog) I have to give it no stars here. So my compromise vote is 3 stars.