Hurleys are a HUGE hit at my house. My girls can be sitting in a room with (literally) a dozen toys and they fight over the Hurley!
My Dobie mix goes through toys in less than 5 minutes. This lasted a few weeks. She loves it. And it was a big help when Miss I-Hate-Water had to undergo PT in a pool. She was frantic and wanting to get out of the pool. I threw the Hurley to the other end and she WOULD go after it! It got her to do some much-needed swimming.
She's gone through at least 3 Hurleys (none lasting more than a few weeks). I tried the Huck and it didn't make it more than a few minutes. I guess she's in that 1% of mega-chewers...
We now have a second rescue who is teething. We're buying more Hurleys - they are still the longest lasting (though nowhere near as tough as claimed, in my experience) and the most popular in our house.