Out of all the toys in the West Paw "Tough Toys" category, this is my dogs favorite one. We have the Hurley and Tux as well, and although both have held up, my dog doesn't really play with those very much. They're too hard for him, he likes toys that have a little more 'chew'. He does however love this Zisc. It's great as a frisbee, easy on his teeth and durable. I keep it in our snowy backyard and it hasn't cracked or disintegrated and it still stays somewhat flexible in the cold so our dog still plays with it tons.