Our three cats adore the West Paw fish. These toys are invariably dug out from the bottom of the pile and carried all over the house. I thought Spout might be a tremendous hit and something new. No, the threesome remain faithful to their favorite. Spout is fine and they seem to like it, even if it hasn't inspired the same level of devotion as the fish. I think it looks very cute. If your floors are decorated with cat toys, too, it's a lovely addition.