I got the dog bone print one (I'd have gotten blue if the store I got it at had had it!) and I have to say its surpassed my expectations so far. Lily loves her plushie toys, but when we play tug and she and my other girl Scout play tug together it tends to quickly disembowel stuffy toys. Lily tugged on it a lot last night with me and not even a creak yet from the fabric where the tail is sewn to the body. I think its definitely worth the purchase and I will certainly purchase another when this eventually dies!