I have bought the Hurley in the past (two, actually) and both got tore up by my Boston Terriers rather quickly. I had a Kong ball that has lasted years until they finally tore that up. Time for a new ball, so I decided to give the Jive a go. Got the largest size hoping that would help and it has as they can't quite get their jaws around it to destroy it. Only small scratches on it so far. Looks like a winner!