Hi West Paw!
My purebred Ocicat Rah Rah is built smaller than most cats. She'll bat around this catnip cat toy for a little while but since she can't toss it far, I think it might be too big for her. I'd recommend making it about a 1/3 smaller. I'm sure big tom cats would like this toy however. Maybe offer it in 2 sizes?
However, the quality is fantastic and I'm glad it's made in America. I like that the fur on this cat toy is real and the leather tail is tough. I like the knot in the end because I can hold it while she bats at it.
Maybe the real problem here is she has too many cat toys!
Thanks for the great pet products made in the USA!